Ask a Jury
Original post
LilyMfnMunster

I had been going on dates with a gentleman for about 5-6 months, nothing progressed beyond occasionally going out together, no spicy time or anything, just company. Due to the fact that whenever I would gently try to build more emotional intimacy (for example we were making plans to spend time together and I made a couple of suggestions but ended with I'm looking more forward to the company than the activity and was met with a little over 24 hours of radio silence) I came to the conclusion that while he enjoyed my company, he just didn't seem that into me and that was ok until my life suddenly got quite complicated in a way that requires me to focus on working, dedicating extra time to my side job, and making some pretty heavy life decisions. I opted to end things with him as it felt like a silly use of my time and mental energy to continue on with a man who showed no real interest in me beyond the occasional outing, I did my best to be as kind as possible.

Report

Report this post?

Are you sure? You’ll sign in first, then tell us why.

Question for the jury

Am I a jerk for "dumping" a guy I wasn't exclusive with when my life got heavy?

The jury is split

3–3

6 jurors voted

Tied350%

You communicated your feelings before ending it.

Tied350%

You prioritized your needs over his feelings.

0

Not enough context.

0

You were clear about the relationship status.

The Jury’s Read

You made a thoughtful choice in prioritizing your own needs during a challenging time. The jury feels you correctly assessed the situation, recognizing that your efforts for greater intimacy were met with silence. Continuing to invest in a relationship where there was little reciprocation would have only added to your stress. This decision isn't a reflection of your character but rather a necessary step for your self-care. The opinions emphasize that you deserve a partnership that supports you, especially when life gets tough.

From the jury

Why they voted

MakoShark94Juror

You’re not the jerk here at all - 5-6 months is plenty of time for him to demonstrate interest. Shit or get off the pot — mans took too long and you up & left. That should register to him as well. You made attempts to elevate the relationship as well and he didn’t reciprocate. Next

Like1
Report

Report this take?

Are you sure? You’ll sign in first, then tell us why.

quietjuror0304Juror

You had a choice. Pleasing him or using “self care”. You could have gotten crumbs so to speak from him and when we are lonely crumbs are a step in the right direction. But he has not outgrown that phase. By not giving you what you need, you always get so to speak “crumbs”. Maybe he sees it differently and my use of the word crumbs sounds inaccurate. What you want is missing and the whole idea of being in a relationship is a mutual give and take. Walking away is self care. It’s not defeat. You did not get what you wanted. But your reason for leaving is self care.

Like0
Report

Report this take?

Are you sure? You’ll sign in first, then tell us why.

JudgeVJuror

You did nothing wrong. I think you read the room correctly and it was smart to remove yourself. That relationship was never going to go anywhere.

Like0
Report

Report this take?

Are you sure? You’ll sign in first, then tell us why.

shut_the_doorJuror

You only get one life Never wrong to dump someone for any reason.

Like0
Report

Report this take?

Are you sure? You’ll sign in first, then tell us why.

StegoJuror

You were stretched thin and found it wasn’t worth your energy to dedicate effort to a relationship that wasn’t being reciprocated. Plus, a partner should make the heavy times in life a bit lighter. You all weren’t serious yet, it sounds like, but you were exclusive. If he wanted a relationship he could’ve and should’ve put even some effort in. Not a jerk at all

Like0
Report

Report this take?

Are you sure? You’ll sign in first, then tell us why.

Your turn

Got something you can’t decide?

Post it anonymously and six people will vote on it. You’ll need an account to post or sit on a jury.